Nixon
In August of 1974, I was a seventeen year-old graduate from Wyoming High School in Wyoming, Ohio, getting ready to go to Denison University. And, I was a “budding” politician, with multiple campaigns under my belt, including working on headquarters planning for the Get Out the Vote operation in a US Congressional Special Election.
And for the past two years, I was steeped in the Watergate scandal. The original break-in of the Democratic National Headquarters in the Watergate office building took place in June of 1972. From that summer on, I absorbed every bit of Watergate information: the early courtroom action, the amazing reporting by Woodward and Bernstein at the Washington Post; the Senate Hearings in the summer of 1973 with the Ervin Committee, and the House Judiciary Committee impeachment hearings in May and June of 1974.
President Nixon used every trick in the book (including “dirty tricks”) to keep the Presidency. But in the end, he was his own undoing. It was his tapes, recordings Nixon made in his own office over the years, that became the coffin nails. By late July of 1974, it was clear that Nixon would be the second President of the United States to be impeached, and likely the first convicted and removed from office.
In those early days of August, as I packed my bags for college, the Gallup Polling organization did their usual Presidential Approval Poll. 24% of Americans still gave Nixon an “approved” rating. But facing sure impeachment and conviction, Nixon resigned.
At seventeen, my friends and I broke open a bottle of champagne.
Approval
24% is not the “record low” for Presidential approval ratings. That honor belongs to Harry Truman at 22%, three weeks before he left office in 1952. George W Bush hit an understandable 25% in October of 2008 in the middle of the stock market crash. Jimmy Carter hit 28% in the summer of the Iran hostage crisis in 1979. And George HW Bush had 29% approval in the summer before the 1992 election, while still in a national recession.
So I guess Donald Trump’s current 30% isn’t really very surprising. After all, none of the other Presidents could be considered a “cult hero”, in the way MAGA adores Trump. And, even on his best day, Trump was still “under water”, with 49% approval. (By the way, Joe Biden’s lowest was 36%, and his highest was 57%). That 30%, much like Nixon’s 24%, might be considered the Trump baseline of support.
Flawed Vessel
Trump also has the further “structure” of the Christian Nationalist’s “flawed vessel” theology. How could a man with known sexual improprieties, even with a legal conviction, be supported so strongly by the religious right? Because he is telling them he will do what they want, what they see as the “work of the Lord”. That “work” excuses all the other flaws. And, of course, if he’s good enough for God, then he’s good enough for them.
If Nixon’s actions in the summer of ’74 didn’t shake the 24% confidence in his Presidency, even with a looming impeachment and removal, nothing could. Trump is in a similar position. No matter how ugly the summer of 2026 becomes: from the debacle in the Middle East, the outright theft of Venezuelan oil (just today), his threats on free and fair elections, and the nonsensical destruction of the Reflecting Pool, the East Wing and now the Kennedy Center; the 30% are sticking with Trump. They are so invested in their belief, that he could (of course) “…shoot someone in the middle of Fifth Avenue and I wouldn’t lose any voters”.
Lost Cause
So, for those who think, “Well, this (fill in the blank) will be the thing, this (fill in the blank) will ‘break the camel’s back’ of Trump’s support”; to use an old New Jersey term, “fuhgeddaboudit”. That won’t happen. And after Trump is finally gone, there will always be that 30%. Like the twentieth century “Lost Cause” Confederates, no amount of fact or consequence will be enough to change their minds.
Since I mentioned the Civil War, it is now “fitting and proper” to extract a phrase from Lincoln’s Gettysburg Address. “It is for us the living, rather, to be dedicated here to the unfinished work…”. By living I mean those of us not in the 30%. Those with our eyes wide open to the risk that Trump creates to our American democracy.
We are at a critical moment. A week from today is Labor Day, the traditional beginnings of political campaigns for November. But you’d have to be a hermit to not see the campaigns have already begun. What happens in Maine and Texas, Georgia and Iowa, Michigan and yes, even here in Ohio, might make all the difference to the America of the future. Our “unfinished work”, is to restore government, of the people, by the people, and most importantly for the people. We can no longer have faith that the “momentum” of the American experiment alone will move us on from this crisis.
As President Kennedy said, “God’s work on earth must truly be our own”.
So let’s get to work.







